Maicki Why Did You Update Save Abandoned

:boom: Puts your console on blast when React is making unnecessary updates.

Project README


why-did-you-update is now deprecated.

Please use @welldone-software/why-did-you-render instead. It supports the latest React, tracks hooks, and does much more to improve performance.

Why did you update

No Maintenance Intended Build Status npm version

Why-did-you-update is a function that monkey patches React and notifies you in the console when potentially unnecessary re-renders occur.


This library is available on npm, install it with: npm install --save why-did-you-update or yarn add why-did-you-update.


You can test the library >> HERE << (notice the console).

Version 1 Update With Breaking Changes

Check out the releases page.

We now only support React 16+

To work with older versions of react, install an older version of this library:

npm install --save [email protected] or yarn add [email protected]


import React from 'react';

if (process.env.NODE_ENV !== 'production') {
  const {whyDidYouUpdate} = require('why-did-you-update');


Optionally you can pass in options as a second parameter. The following options are available:

  • include: [RegExp]
  • exclude: [RegExp]
  • groupByComponent: boolean
  • collapseComponentGroups: boolean
  • notifier: (groupByComponent: boolean, collapseComponentGroups: boolean, displayName: string, diffs: [Object]) => void
include / exclude

You can include or exclude components by their displayName with the include and exclude options

whyDidYouUpdate(React, { include: [/^pure/], exclude: [/^Connect/] });
groupByComponent / collapseComponentGroups

By default, the changes for each component are grouped by component and these groups collapsed. This can be changed with the groupByComponent and collapseComponentGroups options:

whyDidYouUpdate(React, { groupByComponent: true, collapseComponentGroups: false });

A notifier can be provided if the official one does not suit your needs.

const notifier = (groupByComponent, collapseComponentGroups, displayName, diffs) => {
  diffs.forEach(({name, prev, next, type}) => {
    // Use the diff and notify the user somehow
whyDidYouUpdate(React, { notifier });

Common Fixing Scenarios

Value Did Not Change

If you receive the message:

X.[props/state]: Value did not change. Avoidable re-render!`

About the props or the state object of component X, it means the component was rendered although the object is the same:

prevProps === props


prevState === state

Usually renders are caused because of the rendering of their father, or state change. In both cases, at least one of the two would change, at least by reference.

If both the state and the props are the same object, it means the render was caused by this.forceUpdate() or ReactDom.render():

prevProps === props && prevState === state

Not Equal by Reference

If you receive the message:

"X" property is not equal by reference.

This means it received a new object with the same value. For example:

const a = {"c": "d"}
const b = {"c": "d"}
a !== b

To avoid this warning, make sure to not recreate objects:

const a = {"c": "d"}
const b = a
a === b

Changes Are in Functions Only

If you receive the message:

Changes are in functions only. Possibly avoidable re-render?

It's probably because you are creating a function inside render:

  return <div fn={function something(){...}}/>

And this triggers a re-render because:

function something(){...} !== function something(){...}

You can avoid it by binding this function in advance and then reusing it on all renders

  this.something = this.something.bind(this)
  return <div fn={this.something}/>


I originally read about how Benchling created a mixin to do this on a per-component basis (A deep dive into React perf debugging). That is really awesome but also tedious AF, so why not just monkey patch React.


why-did-you-update is MIT licensed.

Open Source Agenda is not affiliated with "Maicki Why Did You Update" Project. README Source: maicki/why-did-you-update
Open Issues
Last Commit
2 years ago

Open Source Agenda Badge

Open Source Agenda Rating